Wednesday, November 2, 2011

Dystopia and English Class in the Computer Lab


English Class in the Computer Lab


One thing I really liked about Tracy Tarasuik's article, "Moving my English Class to the Computer Lab", was her observations and comments on her students' multitasking in the computer lab. This is something I've both seen and done myself during school. In high school, a teacher would send us off to complete various things on the computer and essentially every student would have other tabs open to things like email which they would flip back to while completing their work. I was happy to read the Tarasuik held back on her scoldings to "stay on task" so that she could observe what the students had the capacity to complete.


The survey she designed was a really concise way of getting statistics about the students in her school and getting to know them and their habits better. From these results Tarasuik was able to tailor her lessons and activities so that they would work for her students most efficiently. Tarasuik discovered that some of her students, Robert included, were avid YouTubers; they both watched, filmed, and produced videos on YouTube. Doing this properly requires a lot of skill and effort. Tarasuik knew she had discovered Robert's prominent form of literacy. Unfortunately, in many of today's public schools, websites such as YouTube are blocked from both the students' and teachers' access. I know in my own school district, any video or music streaming website was prohibited for anyone to access or view. I believe this seriously limits the potential of learning from modern media in the classroom. There were many times in my Sociology class that the teacher wanted to show some really relevant YouTube video and simply could not. In the same class, we ran into issues when we were trying to learn about racial issues and bullying; many of these websites were forbidden due to their "inappropriate content". I know this kind of loops back to the censorship discussion...but I still believe these websites shouldn't be restricted as they are far too useful in the classroom.

Given essentially every teacher I've had restricts the use of Wikipedia in the classroom, I was a little concerned when I saw the section header "Wikis", but after reading the section I thought it was a great idea. Tarasuik first had her class look at the wikis of other classes so that they had a good idea of what the could do with their own. The groups were then able to create their own and add to them as they read through their respective novels. This webpage involved teamwork, vocabulary, summaries, characters, and more. Essentially, it's all the good stuff in a worksheet but made digital. Her students were more motivated to do the page as they knew it could potentially be viewed by others online. I think this was a smart lesson idea for Tarasuik's class.


Dystopian Novels


I've found that I actually enjoy reading dystopian novels; I've specifically enjoyed The Giver, The Hunger Games, and The Uglies. Each of these three books [some morphed into series] gives the history behind how their current society came to be. In The Hunger Games:

"An unspecified time before the current date, the face of the Earth changed and modern civilization was seemingly destroyed. It is unknown precisely what caused the "end of the world", but major landmasses changed shape as the sea level rose to unknown heights around the planet. Some time after the end of the world as we knew it, a nation was established in North America that would soon come to be known as Panem. It is unknown precisely when Panem was established and how long it has existed, though it is certain that Panem has been around for more than seventy-five years, and it's entirely possible for it to be at least a century or two old.
Panem eventually grew large enough that it was segmented into thirteen separate districts, each responsible for producing goods of a particular industry to serve the growing needs of the nation, and all operating under the auspices of Panem's oppressive Capitol. Its exact method of expansion is unknown; it is possible that some of the separate districts may have even once been smaller, separate nations that were eventually annexed by Panem."
                                          (http://thehungergames.wikia.com/wiki/Panem)


In the book The Uglies, the world that you and I are currently living in now has been destroyed since we have used too much metal which has rusted, deteriorated, and collapsed after the creation of an "oil bug". This bug made oil combust immediately upon contact with oxygen. The few members of the population who managed to survive combined into cities which they designed to be self-sufficient and eco-friendly so as to prevent another collapse of the world.


I think what I find most interesting about these books is how plausible they all are...I mean we, as a society, really do use far too much metal and oil for our own (and our planet's) good. Something is bound to go incredibly wrong soon. These books are an interesting way to fathom what will happen to the remaining population after such an occurence. 



2 comments:

  1. "Something is bound to go incredibly wrong soon."

    I think this is what I find to be so compelling about these novels as well--the idea that, to a degree, we are already living in a dystopian society, and these novels simply show us how.

    ReplyDelete
  2. In regards to Tarasuik’s article, I’m not sure where I stand. I think that it was good that she didn’t scold students for not staying on task to see what students really could get done, but then again I feel like some boundary should be set because not all students are capable of multi-tasking and many students just often work with the other tabs they have open and never really accomplish anything with the required task or they copy from other students. I think it was a good thing to observe how much students really got done while multi-tasking, but I don’t think this idea of allowing it on a regular basis works for all students.

    I really liked how she created her own survey to find out more about her students and their interests. To me that showed me that she is a very effective teacher and really puts her student’s interests first.

    I also think that by restricting many different websites, it can create a huge restriction in learning but I also think that schools need to do this in some way because there are always those students who are looking up inappropriate content just to get a laugh from other students, etc. I think that the teachers in the school should have some way around the restricted websites so that they can show educational material to the class, however I do think that some restriction needs to be used with the labs in schools, just maybe not as extreme as it is now.

    I also found the dystopian books that we have read for this class to be highly interesting. I really enjoyed reading them and found that it really made me think on a deeper level about what could really happen to our world if things continue the way they are or worsen.

    ReplyDelete