Tuesday, September 27, 2011

Bringing Children Together

I'll admit, when I first looked at the assigned reading that was on the syllabus for this blog post, I immediately skipped over everything but Jane Elliott's Brown Eyed, Blue Eyed experiment. This is something we watched and extensively discussed in my high school Sociology class. I also found the experiment both incredibly fascinating and informative.

After re-experiencing Elliott's experiment, I eventually found my way back to the other assignments on the syllabus for this week. The article, "Reading Multiculturally", by Hade seemed like it would be dull compared to Elliott's video. How very wrong I was! The very first thing Hade spoke about was the Lion King and there is not much that I like more than Disney movies. However, this particular article stretched how I normally think when it comes to Disney movies. I cannot say that I've ever considered the semiotics behind the various characters, nor have I ever noticed that the plot is more representative of the lives of people as opposed to wild animals. I found his analysis very eye-opening. Beyond this, though, Hade states something I'd like to remember as I enter the teaching culture:
"I believed, like many of my colleagues in children's literature, that the power of literature could work miracles, that all I had to do was to bring children together with the right book." (Hade 236)
Just like Elliott, Hade was striving to find something that would unite his students and remove some discrimination from their lives through an increase in understanding. This is definitely something I would like to do with my students. I feel as if having a class that would subtly focus on building bridges between the students. Hade later expounds on why he wants to bring this multiculturalism to the forefront of the classroom:
"I was told that children don't "naturally" read for race, class, and gender, and I mustn't impose my agenda upon them. But what I am after isn't imposing meaning, it is exposing injustice. To ignore the injustice implied in children's stories is a far more insidious way of imposing ideas than to challenge these ideas openly. Silence is the oxygen of racism and bigotry. Silence allows the dominant assumptions about the inferiority of the poor, women, and persons of color to remain unchallenged." (Hade 238)
I want my students to feel comfortable and open to express their feelings and opinions without fear of repercussions or judgement. Ideally, I want my classroom to be a safe place for children to learn.

9 comments:

  1. I loved your quotes that you incorporated. I circled and highlighted the quote, "Silence is the oxygen if racism and bigotry"(Hade 238). This is exactly how I feel about racism, but I could never put it in words. Racism and discrimination should not be ignored, it actually needs to be addressed How do you think you can get your students to feel comfortable to express their feelings and opinions?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Nicole! I have to say that you approached these assignments the same way I did. I think that the video was both terrifying and wonderful. Wonderful in that it served its purpose and put people in the perspective of those who are a minority; yet, terrifying in that the way the children and adults behaved was appalling. I mean these kids were friends with the students they thought they were superior to at one point..now take that to imagine how people feel about those minorities they don't even know. I think this video was real eye-opener and shows how people change. Hade's article, however, was not one that I particularly enjoyed reading as you did. I think it made some really good points but was not what I was expecting. I do agree that teachers go about multiculturalism the wrong way. It is something they brush upon but needs to be fully emphasized for students to actually understand it. I LOVE the Lion King reference. That was my favorite part and it was really true what he was saying.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The quote you chose is one I hope to discuss in more depth in our class tonight! Teachers are often uncertain of their "place" in the "imposing meaning --> exposing injustice" cycle. What responsibility do we have regarding the way we choose to teach these texts in our classrooms. Is Huck Finn just an innocuous story about a boy on a raft or is it something much, much more?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nicole: I also want my classroom to be a safe place for students to learn, somewhere they feel comfortable expressing their thoughts, feelings, and opinions. I get the impression this is difficult to do because many students fear the wrath and judgment of their peers.

    In the college class that I teach, I read a series of bold statements like, "Not everyone should be allowed to have children" and then asked them to stand in different parts of the room based on whether they agreed, disagreed, or were unsure. I then gave them the opportunity to discuss why they chose their answers. I thought the activity was going really well until after class one woman told me that she felt really uncomfortable sharing her opinion because she felt bullied the few times she did share it! I didn't think she was being bullied, but apparently she felt that way, and I felt terrible!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I loved the quotes you incorporated as well. They were some of the ones that I focused on too. The video was an interesting part of our assignment for this week. It was a wonderful project to see and would be even greater to experience. I agree that the article was a very important tool as well and an interesting read. It was weird to hear about movies and books that are so close to our childhood compared to race and gender roles in society.
    It is important for students to be comfortable and be able to discuss aspects of literature that are present in the real world.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Nicole,

    The video was shocking and horrible for me as well. I couldn't believe that fully grown adults would turn on each other that way and believe tht things that they were being told. I'm still in disbelief, really.

    I wrote in my blog as well that I want my classroom to be somewhere safe and comfortable where my students aren't afraid to share their thoughts and feelings. This is probably the most important thing to me. I want the environment to be somewhere the students want to be and feel they can be themselves.

    We discussed a lot in class so I won't go on at length. I wrote off Hade for the most part for his faux pas with the characters' names at the beginning with the example of The Lion King. And while I can see his argument, see where he's getting his points from, I choose to disregard his reading of the text. I do, however, think that he had some good things to say, his advice concerning ingraining multiculturalism into your pedagogy being one of them....you quoted many of the others. :)

    ReplyDelete
  7. I just wanted to say that I love the way you write your blog. You incorperate images of yourself while including important quotes from the section, topped with a classy discussion base. I commend you on your blogging skill.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thank you very much, Emily! I've kept a blog for the better part of the last ten years, I kinda like it. My other blogs are much less academic though. You're welcome to check out my current blog [which doesn't get updated often during the semester because I'm simply too busy :] at optimisticautomatons.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  9. Though, my tumblr is updated pretty much hourly :D

    ReplyDelete